India: a matter of opinion and I’m convinced

The most famous story I know that has its origins in India is that of the blind men and the elephant. It’s a parable that in various forms and tellings has been claimed by Bahá’I, Buddhists, Hindus, Jains, and Sufis.

blindmen1

This story was made famous in Europe when 19th-century American poet John Godfrey Saxe wrote a poem about it, one that has been put to music and animated for use in corporate training workshops dealing with conflict resolution and negotiation. Apparently it’s also found its way into physics classrooms where it’s used as an analogy for wave-particle duality, and into biology labs where it helps explain polyclonal B cell response. Not bad going at all.

Each variation on the same theme cautions us regarding subjective experience and its failure to take all truth into account. Each of the six blind men is asked to describe an elephant. Each touches a particular part of the animal; none touches the whole. Not surprisingly, they each come up with a different answer and then fight amongst themselves to determine who is right.

Differences between the various versions stem from how the parts of the elephant are described. For example, the elephant’s trunk is described as the branch of a tree (Jain), a plough (Buddhist) and a water spout (Sufi). The stories also differ with regard to the degree of conflict between the blind men and how they resolve (or fail to resolve) their arguments.

I was reminded of this when in Hyderabad recently. At lunch one day, conversation turned to the world’s view of India and how so much depends on personal experience. Unlike Ireland or Hungary, in my experience India evokes an either/or response. Either you love it, or you don’t. Many people love/like, hate/dislike or are completely indifferent to Hungary and Ireland. But not so with India.

Those travelling there to do business might return full of enthusiasm for the myriad electronic and technology hubs that are sprouting up in cities such as Bangalore and Greater Noida. They might tout the development the country is undergoing as a commendable sign of progress and growth.

Others might just see the extreme poverty and inequality that breed in the shadows of the high-rise apartments built to house the growing middle class and at the foot of the glass-walled skyscraper complexes built in homage to new industry. They might return with such talk that it would turn others off going at all.

More still might never see the outside of their hotels, tour buses and the routes planned by their guided-tour operators, shielded from anything deemed unsavoury and exposed only to handpicked tourist sites, five-star restaurants  and government-approved vendors.

And, just as in the parable of the blind men and the elephant, to paraphrase Saxe, each one would be partly in the right but all would be in the wrong.

India is an elephant, a massive, glorious, multifaceted beast that takes the concept of extreme to a whole new level. A quick internet search reveals the village of Shani Shingnapur in Maharashtra, a village that is so safe its houses have no doors, its bank has no locks and it has no need for a police station. The village of Pothanikkad in Kerala was the first in the country to reach 100% literacy. The village of Hiware Bazar, also in Maharashtra, boasts 60 millionaires. Imagine.

On the love/hate side, I’m definitely in love. Over the course of three separate visits in ten years, I’ve seen some massive changes and have come to appreciate the differences between north and south. My advice: give it a chance. See for yourself. Take an open mind and an open heart with you and you’ll come home all the richer. Go discover your truth about India.

First published in the Budapest Times 22 January 2016

Share:

Sign up here to get an email whenever I post something new.

Never miss a post

More Posts

Staying local at Kányavári sziget

We dream of islands in the sun. Exotic places where we can get away from it all. We spend hundreds if not thousands of whatevers

Person wearing a kurent costume - horns, devil mask with glowing eyes, wool hair - like a sheep's fleece. Gruesome teeth barred - smoke in the background

Ptuj, Slovenia: Kurentovanje

Shrovetide carnivals like those in Rio de Janeiro, Venice, and New Orleans, need little by way of introduction. They’re well-famous, days-long festivities in the lead-up

One arch of a red iron bridge spanning a wide river. Bridge is reflected in the water as is the cloudless blue sky

Strolling the streets of Maribor, Slovenia

I was surprised that Maribor didn’t make the list of the top 50 most walkable cities in the world. Or even the 33 most walkable

Sobering up in Maribor, Slovenia

Maribor. Maribor. Maribor. The name was embedded in my brain long before I ever set foot in the city. I knew of it because of

Walking through history in Maribor, Slovenia

I’m not a massive fan of museums. Unless they deal with war or resistance or the Holocaust. Or something completely off the wall like the

4 Responses

  1. A *quick* Internet search is the modern equivalent of blindly touching only part of and Elephant.

    A more in depth search would indicate that Shani Shingnapur’s claim to safety is maybe more for the tourists than actually reality. A combination of cultism, legend, tradition and myth combined with a certain degree of isolation until now — its safe myth has brought tourists and ….. crime.

    But as the modern world descends on Shani Shingnapur, its world is changing and some residents are putting locks on their doors:

    See for example: http://www.latimes.com/world/great-reads/la-fg-c1-india-town-no-doors-20151007-story.html

    For what it is worth, I have lived in some places even in the USA where nobody locked their doors. In one house where I rented a down stairs apartment, I did not even have a key to my apartment, the owner lost them years ago.

  2. In Alaska we would leave our cars running with the keys in the ignition – took me a while to get used to that. And I didn’t have a key to my cabin there, either. That would be unheard of in Ireland.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 Responses

  1. A *quick* Internet search is the modern equivalent of blindly touching only part of and Elephant.

    A more in depth search would indicate that Shani Shingnapur’s claim to safety is maybe more for the tourists than actually reality. A combination of cultism, legend, tradition and myth combined with a certain degree of isolation until now — its safe myth has brought tourists and ….. crime.

    But as the modern world descends on Shani Shingnapur, its world is changing and some residents are putting locks on their doors:

    See for example: http://www.latimes.com/world/great-reads/la-fg-c1-india-town-no-doors-20151007-story.html

    For what it is worth, I have lived in some places even in the USA where nobody locked their doors. In one house where I rented a down stairs apartment, I did not even have a key to my apartment, the owner lost them years ago.

  2. In Alaska we would leave our cars running with the keys in the ignition – took me a while to get used to that. And I didn’t have a key to my cabin there, either. That would be unheard of in Ireland.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.